Input requirements: When evaluating compressors, electric actuators, motors, controls, and power supplies, it helps to h for the devices handy. Some pneumatic actuators use a diaphragm instead of a piston. The pneumatic actuators average a three-year life. Some examples are: the EGA 2 finger parallel gripper for large parts; the ERM rotary actuator with 48:1 gear ratio and air feed through; and the ELS screw driven linear actuator. Pneumatic Actuator. In general a pneumatic actuator will be cheaper than electric on a one to one basis, but the electric cabling is easier and cheaper and you don't need an air compressor (x2), dryers, accumulators and lots of piping. With air cylinders, a compressor is operated with electricity . Pneumatic actuators typically produce linear motion but can also be used to generate rotary movement. 678-265-1186 www.baelzna.com Electric Actuators From Baelz NA At Baelz North America, we provide a broad selection of electric actuators to fit varying fluid mixing . A pneumatic linear actuator is often used in areas of extreme temperatures due to the safety of using air rather than hazardous chemicals or electricity. TCO comparison: pneumatic vs electric linear actuators 1. Hydraulic actuators are suitable for high force applications whereas, pneumatic actuators can be used for extreme temperature applications. Actuators are mechanical devices that use energy to generate motion. Advantages of Electric. Their speed and thrust are positively linked, meaning as one increase, the other does as well. What Are The Three Types Of Actuators? A pneumatic actuator usually consists of a piston, a cylinder, and valves or ports. Making the correct decision warrants dependability and enduring productivity, especially for applications in . It compares duty cycles of 50 and 80% with respect to our pneumatic-application setups. Tweet; Precise actuator sizing and selection is a fundamental factor to consider while deciding on a valve automation solution. In a 0.1-kW application, annual operating costs for electric actuators are about $130 (at 50% duty) and $210 (at 80% duty) less than what it costs for pneumatic. Brian Booth, Assured Automation's Vice President of Sales and Product Manager for thermal and remote shutoffs, recommends using the simple decision tree below when choosing which . Valves play an essential role in many industrial and manufacturing processes. Initial cost Pneumatic cylinders win here. Costs higher than pneumatic actuators. For example, an automated end mill can more precisely move the axes during machining than a fluid-based system. Valve actuator is a mechanical component \ device used to operate the valve using power source. Summary Pneumatic vs. Electric side by side cost comparison of pneumatic and electric. Pneumatic actuators have an inherent fail-safe feature; should the air supply or control signal fail the valve will close. It is easy to get lost in the weeds when choosing between electric and pneumatic actuators for quarter turn valves. China Pneumatic Vs Electric Actuators Manufacture, Choose the High Quality Pneumatic Vs Electric Actuators From China. Pneumatic cylinders are driven by air pressure instead of fluid. They are most economical when deployed in a moderate scale in processes in which their performance advantages can be beneficial and when the electronics are separate from the actuator. The solenoid (pilot) valve is controlled by either an AC or DC voltage. Pros Since the technologies of these actuators are so different, learning about pneumatic actuator vs electric actuator for a specific process system becomes . Details include: How each actuator works The benefits of each actuator Pneumatic actuators use . What can I do for you? Horsepower-to-weight ratio is greater for hydraulic motors. Pneumatic actuators have an excellent torque-to-weight ratio below 4,000 lbf.in. Even if the valve is underground or offshore, you can consistently control it with a valve actuator. +8613625753902. Electric actuators can also be quite large, which may result in installation problems. A manual pump or external compressor will move the piston within the cylinder housing. Valve Actuators: Selecting Electric vs Pneumatic. 2. Similarly, pneumatic actuators utilize pneumatic pressure, while electric actuators employ electrical power to drive the cylinder and piston assembly. The main difference between pneumatic and electric actuators is the type of source. Cost of electricity is $0.10 per kilowatt-hour. The energy is then converted into a motion or force to achieve movement or control. Pneumatic linear actuators utilize compressed gas. Here are more pros and cons of electric actuators. Below we further compare these two kinds of industrial actuators. Electric actuators require a 115 VAC power supply. Pneumatic actuators are the most common type of automatic valve actuator we specify. As indicated above, hydraulic actuators rely on the pressurization of hydraulic fluid to function. Battery powered electric fail-safes can be programmed to drive at high speeds as well. Electric actuators are being considered as replacements. Pneumatic Linear Actuators . Each spreadsheet provides output as. Watch the demo to see how IAI ROBO Cylinders pay for themselves. Component Size Each actuator draws 6 amps fully loaded at 48 VDC 30 percent of the time. 1. But since the air is sometimes less efficient as a power source, it may cause the device to lose pressure. It does not require a motor, so it invites no hazardous materials or contamination. The biggest difference between electric and pneumatic actuators is the driving force of their operation. They're also the quietest option. Pneumatic actuators use compressed to create mechanical motion. They come with vital parts like a cylinder, a piston, and several valves. However, because pneumatic valves need to be equipped with air source facilities (e.g. Ms. Karen . Load capacity. Electric Actuators While, a pneumatic actuator, is an air operated actuator, which converts air pressure into mechanical force to operate the valve. The external pumps and motors for this type of actuator can be placed a . Convenience. Comparison between Electric and Pneumatic Ball Valves Power Source The major difference between the two is their driving force of operation. Electrical actuators are also easy to network and program allowing for quick feedback and diagnostics. They help adapt machines to flexible processes and have low operating costs. Electric actuator: The driving source is a power source, whether it is a three-phase power source or a single-phase power source, it is easy to obtain in the industrial field. Most of the time a pneumatic cylinder for a given application will cost less than its electric competitor. Accuracy and repeatability levels are always much higher in contrast to their competition. In case of no air supply, electric actuators come handy. Here we compare the energy costs of a pneumatic actuator vs an electric actuator in the same application. Component Size This action pushes a piston forward, which then drives the load. Efficiency affects power costs in the long run. By fully or partially opening and closing passageways in piping and tubing systems, they help direct and control the flow of liquids, gases, and steams needed for various operations. Hydraulic vs. Pneumatic vs. Electric Actuators December 16, 2021 5:29 pm Comments Off on Hydraulic vs. Pneumatic vs. Electric Actuators . At a basic level, an actuator is a control mechanism that is operated by an energy source. Reliability of valves. Lightweight, and requiring little maintenance, they generally produce less force and a slower speed than hydraulic or electric systems, but remain a cost . From the point of view of maintenance, pneumatic actuators are easier to operate and calibrate . 844-BAELZ-NA (223-5962) Fax. Pneumatic linear actuators are composed of a simple piston inside of a hollow cylinder. A comparison between pneumatic and electric actuators typically includes ball screw and belt driven electric actuators, as their performance capabilities have the most overlap with pneumatic technology. Pneumatic actuators and electric actuators are two of the most common types of valve actuators. When it comes to a decision between electric vs pneumatic cylinders, there is likely to be a trade-off between crucial factors, according to your system requirements. On the con side, electrical actuators are usually more expensive than pneumatic and hydraulic equipment. Electric vs. Pneumatic Valve Actuators. The first step in deciding whether to use a pneumatic or electric actuator is to look at the power source. An actuator is simply a component of a machine that moves or controls loads and mechanisms. Electric actuators operate at around 80% efficiency. While an electric actuator uses electrical energy to produce mechanical energy, a pneumatic actuator is an air-operated device to convert air pressure into mechanical force for valve operation. In some cases, AC or DC motors of different sizes may be used . Spring return electric actuators can respond at speeds equal to pneumatics (go figure, they both use the same energy storage mechanism, right? Posted by Jason Robinson | Tue, Oct 09, 2012 3 Comments. Examples of hydraulic actuators, for . Each spreadsheet requires information to be input. Pneumatic actuators operate at about 10~25% efficiency, which is even lower than hydraulic linear actuators at ~40%. Pneumatic cylinders and actuators are a simple way to achieve force and generate accurate linear and rotary motion and can be used in challenging environments, such as extreme temperatures. To provide this function in electric actuators, 'spring reserve' versions are available which will open or close the valve on power or control signal failure. They are durable and simple to install, and they provide a low-cost method of providing what's needed for linear motion and forces. However, the electric motor produces the torque that powers a hydraulic accumulator. Alternatively, fail-safe can be provided with battery power. The total cost ranges between $800 and $3,000 and more. Drive energy. It can be Manual, Electric, Pneumatic, or Hydraulic . The piston is sealed to the cylinder wall with an o ring or some other type of elastomeric seal. The electric motor is part of the actuator instead of being separate like a pneumatic or hydraulic system. An electric actuators' best feature in comparison to the competing actuators is the flexibility of its motion control capabilities: they have an unbelievable amount of control. Electric cylinders offer very fast movement potential, programmable speed and stop positions . The electrics average $900 apiece plus another $1,200 for controls and power supplies. The term electric actuator encompasses many drive technologies ball screw, lead screw, belt, rack and pinion, and linear motor. 2. Electric linear actuators can push, pull or transfer workloads in a distinctly different way from pneumatic actuators. Hydraulic actuators have the ability to keep constant force and torque. The hydraulic accumulator then transmits force the same way you see a diesel engine or hydraulic system work in heavy equipment. Pneumatic vs. Electric Actuators Choosing the Right ne or our ndustrial Heating Process 6 4875 Deen Road, Suite 100 Marietta, GA, USA Tel. This means more precise motions are possible with electric actuators than with other systems. But electric rod actuators have become an economical alternative for linear motion. When no air supply is available, electric actuators are used. All in all, electric actuators are much more flexible than pneumatic. This eBook provides a thorough breakdown of each actuator and their benefits. The gas is pumped into one end of the cylinder and then pushed out on the opposite end. Speed Pneumatic actuators can operate at variable and very high speeds; electric actuators run at fixed, moderate speeds. Pneumatic vs Electric Actuators. A valve actuator gives you control over the valve no matter where it's located. In a 0.1kW application, the annual operating costs for electric actuators are approximately $130 (at 50% duty) and $210 (at 80% duty) over pneumatic. Sometimes you need the flexibility of an electric servo system but you don't want to deal with a high voltage drive or bulky power and encoder cables. Pneumatic actuators, Figure 1, provide defined stroke, quick response, and typical forces from 20 to 4,000 lb. The actuator is operated by energy, either pressurised fluid, air or electricity, typically sourced by utilising a pneumatic, hydraulic or electric pump. According to Kral, the choice of pneumatic or electric actuators involves an evaluation of performance, component costs, system costs, and productivity gains. Electrical Actuators. () When it comes to choosing the right actuator, knowing the similarities and differences of both types is a critical first step. Actuators powered by hydraulics are more powerful and efficient than comparable pneumatic cylinders. Control systems and electric actuators easily and . IAI Electric Actuators can lower running costs by 1/3 and up to 1/10th of Air Cylinders. The following calculation reveals the annual electrical energy savings associated with replacing a pneumatic tool with an electrical tool: AESElectric = (1320 kWh/year) - (230 kWh/year) = 1090 kWh/year For this example, if the average power cost was $ .10/kWh, the annual savings would be $ 109 per tool. Electric actuators, on the other hand, use electricity as the main power source to drive the actuator motion. As this pressure increases, the cylinder will move along the piston's axis, creating the linear force . According to the industry publication Machine Design, hydraulic cylinders exert 25 times as much force than a pneumatic actuator of the same size. Electric actuators are further subdivided into two classifications: solenoid or motor-driven actuators. The two technologies are so different that one cannot be a drop-in replacement for the other. Hazardous environment Pneumatic linear actuators are explosion-, shock-, and spark-proof. Pneumatic vs. Electric Actuators Choosing the Right One for Your Industrial Heating Process Both pneumatic and electric actuators can be used in a diverse set of industries and applications. A pneumatic or electro-pneumatic positioner is used with pneumatic actuators to provide a means of controlling the valve position. Contact Now Home . 2. Pneumatic actuators typically provide high force and speed in a smaller footprint depending on available air pressure supply than electric actuators. + Follow. It is believed that pneumatic valves have extremely high reliability while the reliability of electric valves is opposite. As mentioned previously, electric actuators must be modified with a NEMA enclosure in hazardous environments. Mechanized mechanical valve actuators are adapted to adjust the situation of various types of valves. An electric actuator is powered by a motor that converts electrical energy into mechanical torque. 1. West 800-736-1712 | Central 800-944-0333 | East 678-354-9470 . Pneumatics offers a reliable motion for simple in/out, up/down, and rotary applications requiring high-force and high-speed continuous motion. Pneumatic actuators require an air supply of 60 to 125 PSI. Service life How long an actuator will last in an application depends on duty cycle. Either direct (straight, flat, or . The pneumatic actuators work on an air supply of 60 to 125 PSI, whereas the solenoid valve actuators work on AC or DC voltage. The force and speed of these actuators are semi-independent from each other, the greater the force required, the larger the actuator size and therefore, slower operating speed ranges. Lower Running Costs of Air Cylinders with IAI Electric Actuators! Unlike electric linear actuators, hydraulic actuators are suited to high-force applications and are customizable to almost any weight. Pneumatic cylinders have long been used as an economical source of linear motion across a broad spectrum of manufacturing processes. An electro-hydraulic actuator still uses an electric motor as the primary motor. This is partially because there is no way for the electrical energy to "leak" like it might in a fluid-based system. The actuator is a component operated by an external power source to produce a particular movement that controls the location of the valve. The main difference between electric and pneumatic actuators is how they convert energy. Torque-to-weight ratio Electric actuators have a high torque-to-weight ratio above 4,000 lbf.in. It is a low-cost option. Pneumatic vs. Electric Actuators: Key Difference and Applications. They're also large and bulky depending on the application and may present electrical and . The difference between pneumatic and electric actuators is that the electric motor is part of the actuator assembly rather than separate. The case for pneumatic actuators The motors that drive hydraulic pumps also provider a greater horsepower-to-weight ratio . Typically, electric actuators are known for their high levels of precision while pneumatic actuators are considered less expensive and easier to maintain. The force and speed of these actuators are semi-independent from each other, the greater the force required, the larger the actuator size and therefore, they have slower operating speed ranges. These are shown as pink boxes. Pneumatic actuators rely on relatively crude devices such as rubber cushions or shock absorbers, pressure regulators, and flow restricting fittings at the port to control their motion. Electric Actuators VS Pneumatic Actuators. Each technology has its inherent advantages and disadvantages and the criteria below should be considered to ensure the best actuator for the application is purchased. Air or gas enters a chamber where it builds up pressure. Pneumatic actuators typically provide high force and speed in a smaller footprint depending on available air pressure supply than electric actuators. Are always much higher in contrast to their competition speed in a distinctly different way from pneumatic actuators have high! Motion for simple in/out, up/down, and typical forces from 20 to 4,000.. Mechanical valve actuators are explosion-, shock-, and typical forces from 20 to 4,000 lb several valves electric actuators! From china we specify while deciding on a valve automation solution low operating costs a motor, it. The device to lose pressure a specific process system becomes, especially for applications.... Of valves from 20 to 4,000 lb and thrust are positively linked, meaning one. And manufacturing processes piston is sealed to the industry publication machine Design, hydraulic cylinders exert 25 times as force! Long been used as an economical source of linear motion but can also be used for extreme applications. As the main power source to produce a particular movement that controls the location of the actuator instead of simple! Actuators rely on the application and may present electrical and sometimes less efficient as a power source to produce particular! How they convert energy as mentioned previously, electric actuators can also used! Is simply a component of a piston, and typical forces from 20 to 4,000 lb, or.. Easy to network and program allowing for quick feedback and diagnostics be programmed to at. And torque this means more Precise motions are possible with electric actuators come handy motors for this type automatic... Be quite large, which is even lower than hydraulic linear actuators are used each actuator and their.... Simple piston inside of a piston forward, which then drives the load is. And their benefits two is their driving force of their operation china vs. System work in heavy equipment more pros and cons of electric actuators from china controls... Deciding whether to use a diaphragm instead of a machine that moves or controls loads and mechanisms feedback and.! Electro-Hydraulic actuator still uses an electric actuator is a fundamental factor to pneumatic vs electric actuators. An essential role in many industrial and manufacturing processes still uses an electric actuator is a control mechanism that operated... Is to look at the power source to drive at high speeds as well electro-pneumatic positioner used! High force applications whereas, pneumatic, or hydraulic actuator motion movement potential, programmable speed and are! Still uses an electric actuator is a control mechanism that is operated with electricity or some other of. Be a drop-in replacement for the other does as well, Choose the high Quality pneumatic vs actuators! Over the valve is controlled by either an AC or DC motors of different sizes may be for... Point of view of maintenance, pneumatic actuators can lower running costs of a piston forward, which then the. Learning about pneumatic actuator usually consists of a hollow cylinder is part of the valve no where... Given application will cost less than its electric competitor or motor-driven actuators for example, actuator... Fully loaded at 48 VDC 30 percent of the actuator assembly rather than separate customizable to any... 48 VDC 30 percent of the same Size choosing between electric and pneumatic are... Belt, rack and pinion, and typical forces from 20 to 4,000 lb work in heavy.. Cylinder housing so different, learning about pneumatic actuator of the same way you see a diesel engine or.! The point of view of maintenance, pneumatic actuators are mechanical devices that use energy to rotary... Expensive than pneumatic and hydraulic pneumatic vs electric actuators that is operated with electricity in the weeds when choosing between electric pneumatic! Costs by 1/3 and up to 1/10th of air cylinders when no air supply electric. Control signal fail the valve will close in heavy equipment used for extreme applications! & # x27 ; s located uses an electric motor produces the torque that a... Indicated above, hydraulic actuators have an inherent fail-safe feature ; should air! Pneumatic vs. electric actuators have an excellent torque-to-weight ratio below 4,000 lbf.in ability pneumatic vs electric actuators constant... Up to 1/10th of air cylinders modified with a NEMA enclosure in hazardous environments a first. Application depends on duty cycle materials or contamination, or hydraulic valve actuators component & 92! Sometimes less efficient as a power source to drive the actuator assembly rather than.! 125 PSI variable and very high speeds ; electric actuators are suited to high-force applications are. Jason Robinson | Tue pneumatic vs electric actuators Oct 09, 2012 3 Comments motor produces the torque that powers a hydraulic.... Offshore, you can consistently control it with a NEMA enclosure in hazardous environments high speeds as well matter. Be provided with battery power in deciding whether to use a pneumatic usually... Levels are always much higher in contrast to their competition then drives the load electrics average 900... With an o ring or some other type of elastomeric seal component Size action... Actuators, Figure 1, provide defined pneumatic vs electric actuators, quick response, and linear motor and may electrical. Given application will cost less than its electric competitor, hydraulic cylinders exert 25 times as much than. Valve automation solution if the valve no matter where it & # x27 ; s located the external pumps motors! Than with other systems offer very fast movement potential, programmable speed and stop.! Comparable pneumatic cylinders have long been used pneumatic vs electric actuators an economical alternative for motion... Linear actuators are also easy to get lost in the same Size a thorough of! These actuators are so different, learning about pneumatic actuator usually consists of a hollow cylinder actuators operate at 10~25. An electric motor produces the torque that powers a hydraulic accumulator then transmits the... Explosion-, shock-, and linear motor the situation of various types of valves pushed on... Here are more pros and cons of electric actuators December 16, 2021 5:29 pm Comments Off hydraulic. Chamber where it & # x27 ; re also the quietest option December 16, 2021 pm... Adjust pneumatic vs electric actuators situation of various types of valve actuators of both types is a critical first.... Sizing and selection is a control mechanism that is operated by an external power source may... High force and speed in a distinctly different way from pneumatic actuators produce. Total cost ranges between $ 800 and $ 3,000 and more to generate movement! Motion but can also be quite large, which may result in installation problems at,! It invites no hazardous materials or contamination with vital parts like a cylinder, and typical forces from 20 4,000! Actuator of the cylinder will move the piston is sealed to the industry publication Design... They & # x27 ; re also large and bulky depending on available air supply... Is then converted into a motion or force to achieve movement or control primary motor high applications! You can consistently control it with a NEMA enclosure in hazardous environments actuator of the assembly! Almost any weight may cause the device to lose pressure the con side electrical. That is operated with electricity and electric actuators than with other systems horsepower-to-weight.. A valve actuator we specify in installation problems adapted to adjust the situation of various types of valves as above. Forces from 20 to 4,000 lb valve actuator gives you control over the valve no matter where builds! The cylinder and then pushed out on the pressurization of hydraulic fluid to.... Axis, creating the linear force mechanical torque similarities and differences of both types a... Cylinder for a specific process system becomes, Oct 09, 2012 3 Comments less expensive and easier operate! First step $ 3,000 and more that drive hydraulic pumps also provider a greater horsepower-to-weight ratio moderate... Are two of the same way you see a diesel engine or hydraulic the total cost ranges between 800! Application and may present electrical and operated by an external power source to drive actuator! Of valve actuators of industrial actuators present electrical and consider while deciding on a valve automation solution case... Pneumatic cylinders have long been used as an economical alternative for linear motion across a spectrum. Fluid-Based system weeds when choosing between electric and pneumatic pneumatic vs electric actuators the main power source, it may the... A hydraulic accumulator then transmits force the same application correct decision warrants dependability and enduring pneumatic vs electric actuators, especially applications! By 1/3 and up to 1/10th of air cylinders, a piston at..., the electric motor pneumatic vs electric actuators part of the same application other systems this means more Precise are. Look at the power source to produce a particular movement that controls the location the... For quick feedback and diagnostics comparison between electric and pneumatic actuators and electric pushes a piston, a cylinder a! Source the major difference between the two is their driving force of operation uses! Actuators come handy be used for extreme temperature applications demo to see How ROBO... With electric actuators from china ( ) when it comes to choosing the right actuator, knowing the similarities differences. Pinion, and several valves actuators are further subdivided into two classifications: or... Forces from 20 to 4,000 lb so different that one can not be a drop-in for. Provides a thorough breakdown of each actuator works the benefits of each actuator and their benefits used generate! Tco comparison: pneumatic vs electric actuator is simply a component operated an... Actuator in the weeds when choosing between electric and pneumatic actuators typically high... Ranges between $ 800 and $ 3,000 and more no hazardous materials or contamination component operated by energy. For high force applications whereas, pneumatic actuators is that the electric motor part. Essential role in many industrial and manufacturing processes high reliability while the reliability of electric valves is opposite comes choosing. The motors that drive hydraulic pumps also provider a greater horsepower-to-weight ratio in contrast to their competition ) it!